Skip to main content

Why "Can’t" Often Looks Like "Won’t"

"Pick up your socks."
"Start your math homework."
"Get in the bath."

To us, these are simple requests. But for some kids, these everyday "demands" trigger an immediate, intense "NO." It doesn't matter how nicely you ask or what reward you offer; the moment a demand is placed on them, they shut down, argue, or even run away. In the clinical world, we might call this Pathological Demand Avoidance (PDA) or a "non-compliance" issue.

But at my kitchen table, I call it The Internal Seesaw. The clever and healing insight here is that your child isn't trying to be the boss of you; they are trying to be the boss of themselves because they feel like they’re losing their balance.

The Clever Insight: Autonomy vs. Threat

Think of your child’s nervous system as a Seesaw.

  • Side A is Autonomy: This is their sense of control, safety, and "I can do this."
  • Side B is The Demand: This is any expectation from the outside world.

For a neurotypical brain, the seesaw is pretty sturdy. You can pile a few "demands" on one side, and the brain just adjusts. But for a child with a sensitive "Seesaw," a single demand feels like a 50-pound weight being dropped onto one side.

When that weight hits, their side (Autonomy) flies up into the air. In that moment, their brain registers a Threat Signal. They aren't just "being difficult"—their amygdala is screaming that they have lost their safety. The "No" you hear is actually a survival reflex. They are trying to jump back onto their side of the seesaw to bring things back into balance.

Identifying the "Seesaw" Slant

When a child’s seesaw is tipped, you’ll see these "Survival Strategies" instead of simple "refusal":

  1. The "Distraction" Pivot: They suddenly become incredibly interested in something else, or they start a conversation about a totally different topic to "lighten" the weight of the demand.
  2. The "Negotiation" Loop: They try to change the rules. "I'll do it, but only if I can wear my dinosaur hat and use a purple pen." They are trying to add "Autonomy" weights back to their side.
  3. The Physical Shutdown: They might literally go limp, hide under a table, or "lose the ability" to use their hands. Their system has moved from "Fight" into "Freeze."

Demonstrating the "Leveling" Strategy

If we want them to follow a request, we have to stop dropping weights and start leveling the seesaw.

  1. Declarative Language (The "Side-by-Side" Ask): Instead of a direct command ("Go brush your teeth"), try making an observation: "I noticed the toothbrush is waiting for you." This removes the "weight" of the direct demand and allows them to "choose" to take action. It keeps their Autonomy side grounded.
  2. The Power of Choice (Adding Counter-Weights): Always give them a way to feel in control. "It’s time to clean up. Do you want to pick up the red blocks or the blue ones first?" By giving them a choice, you are adding "Autonomy Weights" to their side of the seesaw at the same time you place the demand.
  3. Collaborative Problem Solving: If they are stuck, join their side of the seesaw. "This math page feels really heavy today. Should we do the first one together, or should I read the questions while you write?"

An Insightful Resource: The "Demand Audit"

Try a "Demand Audit" for one afternoon. Count how many times you use a "Imperative" (a direct command like Do, Go, Get, Stop). Then, see if you can flip half of them into "Declarative" observations.

  • Old way: "Put your coat on."
  • New way: "It’s chilly out, I’m putting my coat on so I stay warm." Notice if their "refusal" drops when the "threat" of the demand is removed.

The Ultimate Daily Win: The "Self-Initiated" Shift

The biggest win is when you see your child feel safe enough to balance the seesaw themselves.

Yesterday, my daughter was staring at her room, which was a disaster. I knew if I said "Clean this up," her seesaw would slam down. Instead, I sat on the floor and said, "Man, there are so many toys here, I can't even see the rug!" I didn't ask her to do anything. I just made an observation.

She looked around, sighed, and said, "I'll put the Legos away so we can walk." She felt the "weight" of the mess, but because I didn't add the "weight" of a command, she had enough Autonomy to handle it herself. She balanced her own seesaw.

Moving Forward: SEO and Long-Term Peace

When parents search for "oppositional defiance" or "how to get a child to listen," they are often given strategies based on "asserting authority." But with a "Seesaw Child," more authority just means more weight, which means a bigger "No."

By understanding the Internal Seesaw today, you are moving from a "Power Struggle" to "Safety Support." You are teaching your child that they are safe, even when the world has expectations.

Take a look at your "demands" today. Are you dropping weights, or are you helping them stay balanced? You’re doing a beautiful job being their level ground!